Research Report
Jesper Augustsson, Anders Esko, Roland Thomeé, Ulla Svantesson
Resistance training is commonly used in sports for prevention of injuries and in rehabilitation. The purpose of this study was to compare closed versus open kinetic chain weight training of the thigh muscles and to determine which mode resulted in the greatest performance enhancement. Twenty-four healthy subjects were randomized into a barbell squat or a knee extension and hip adduction variable resistance weight machine group and performed maximal, progressive weight training twice a week for 6 weeks. All subjects were tested prior to training and at the completion of the training period. A barbell squat 3-repetition maximum, an isokinetic knee extension 1-repetition maximum, and a vertical jump test were used to monitor effects of training. Significant improvements were seen in both groups in the barbell squat 3-repetition maximum test. The closed kinetic chain group improved 23 kg (31%), which was significantly more than the 12 kg (13%) seen in the open kinetic chain group. In the vertical jump test, the closed kinetic chain group improved significantly, 5 cm (10%), while no significant changes were seen in the open kinetic chain group. A large increase of training load was observed in both subject groups; however, improvements in isotonic strength did not transfer to the isokinetic knee extension test. The results may be explained by neural adaptation, weight training mode, and specificity of tests.
J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 1998;27(1):3-8.
Key Words: resistance training, free weights, weight machines, lower extremity
View Abstract
View Full Article
Research Report
Teddy W. Worrell, Michael D. Ross
Girth measures are commonly used to assess muscle atrophy or joint effusion. Little is known, however, regarding girth measurement changes following knee injury and subsequent surgery. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to compare the thigh and calf girth measurements of involved and noninvolved extremities prior to and following knee surgery for subjects with acute and chronic knee injuries. Of the 40 subjects that were studied, 22 subjects were placed in the acute group (less than 6 months from time of injury to presurgery measurement) and 18 subjects were placed in the chronic group (greater than 6 months from time of injury to presurgery measurement). Thigh and calf girth measurements were taken prior to surgery and then prior to the initiation of outpatient rehabilitation following surgery. For the acute and chronic groups, a 3-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) with repeated measures on the extremity, muscle, and time factors was used to analyze the data. For each group, the 3-way ANOVA revealed a significant 2-way interaction between the extremity and time factors. Post hoc analysis revealed significant differences between involved and noninvolved extremities at both the pre- and postsurgery time periods for the acute and chronic groups. While thigh and calf girth measurement differences existed between the involved and noninvolved extremities prior to and after surgery, the bulk of the girth measurement differences existed prior to surgery for both groups. Based upon the results of this study, the assessment and rehabilitation of the thigh and calf following knee injury and surgery are recommended.
J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 1998;27(1):9-15.
Key Words: knee, surgery, thigh girth, calf girth
View Abstract
View Full Article
Research Report
Sharon E. Turl, Keith P. George
The etiology and nature of repetitive hamstring strain is complex and not fully understood. The purpose of this study was to investigate the presence of adverse neural tension in 14 male Rugby Union players with a history of grade I repetitive hamstring strain. Comparison was made to an injury-free matched control group. Adverse neural tension was assessed using the slump test. Hamstring flexibility was measured using the active knee extension in lying test. Results indicated that 57% of the test group had positive slump tests, suggesting the presence of adverse neural tension. None of the control group had a positive slump test. Analysis of variance revealed no differences in flexibility between groups or between those demonstrating a positive or negative slump test. Results suggest that adverse neural tension may result from or be a contributing factor in the etiology of repetitive hamstring strain. Residual decreased flexibility is not apparent in this subject group.
J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 1998;27(1):16-21.
Key Words: neural tension, repetitive hamstring strain, slump test
View Abstract
View Full Article
Research Report
Allen W. Jackson, James R. Morrow, Patricia A. Brill, Harold W. Kohl, Neil F. Gordon, Steven N. Blair
The sit-up and sit-and-reach tests are found on nearly all youth and adult fitness tests because of the perceived relation between performance on these tests and low back pain. However, this relationship has not been well validated. Therefore, the purpose of the study was to examine the relationship between performance on these 2 common field tests of muscular strength and flexibility (the sit-up and the sit-and-reach tests) and self-reported low back pain (LBP). The sample included 2,747 adults with a mean age of 44.6 ± 9.8 years. The 1-minute sit-up (mean = 30.9 ± 10.6) and sit-and-reach tests (mean = 39.88 ± 10.49 cm) were administered to participants as part of a voluntary clinical health and fitness evaluation between 1980 and 1990. Participants completed a mail-back survey in 1990 on musculoskeletal health problems. Low back pain was quantified by developing an ordinal variable from questionnaire responses, which represented a range of severity of LBP from none (0) to LBP that required medical care (3). With an average of 6.1 (± 2.0) years of follow-up, LBP was reported by 54% of the study participants (men = 45%, women = 54%). Pearson correlations between sit-up (r = .002; p = .94), sit-and-reach (r = -.043; p = .03), and LBP indicated poor LBP criterion-related validity from the sit-up and sit-and-reach tests. Partial correlations, where age, gender, percent of body fat, and time between testing and survey response were controlled, displayed no increase in the relationship. This study does not support the validity of sit-up and sit-and-reach test items for health-related fitness batteries because they were unrelated to LBP.
J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 1998;27(1):22-26.
Key Words: low back pain, health fitness, survey
View Abstract
View Full Article
Research Report
Iris F. Kimura, Dawn T. Gulick, Jennifer Shelly, Marvin C. Ziskin
Ultrasound is a commonly used therapeutic modality for which there is little research on the effect of treatment dosage on the extent of tissue heating. The purpose of this study was to investigate the effect of 2 different ultrasound devices, angle of ultrasound application, and treatment time on the temperature of a tissue phantom. Four trials were performed at 4 ultrasound application angles (90°, 80°, 70°, and 60°) with both an Excel UltraMax and a Mettler Sonicator 720. A continuous 1-MHz frequency at 2.0 W/cm2 was administered for 5 minutes, with tissue phantom temperature recorded at 1-minute intervals. The analysis of the data revealed significant main effects between ultrasound devices, angle of application, and treatment times. Interactions were identified between ultrasound device and treatment times and angle of application and treatment times. Analysis of simple effects revealed significant differences between ultrasound devices after 2, 3, 4, and 5 minutes of treatment and between treatment times and 80° and 60° angles of application. Maximal temperature increase after a 5-minute treatment was 2.025°C. This level of tissue heating falls below expected values and may not yield therapeutic results. The thermal effects were noted to be greatest at 80° and 90° angles of application. Despite appropriate calibration and identical treatment protocols, the 2 ultrasound devices yielded significantly different tissue phantom temperatures, which were notably lower than expected values. We concluded that direct monitoring of ultrasound device output and calculation of treatment dosage should occur on a routine basis, as treatment outcome will certainly be affected by the actual dosage of ultrasonic energy.
J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 1998;27(1):27-31.
Key Words: ultrasound, therapeutic heating, tissue phantom
View Abstract
View Full Article
Clinical Commentary
Jill M. Thein-Nissenbaum, Lori Thein Brody
Elite athletes are competing for longer seasons, training more hours, and taking less time off. This schedule may predispose the elite athlete to overuse injuries. When an injury occurs, aquatic-based rehabilitation may expedite the recovery process, as effective cardiovascular and musculoskeletal training may be accomplished by aquatic exercise. The pool may be used both during rehabilitation and postrecovery as an adjunctive tool. Knowledge of the unique physical properties of water, as well as the physiological responses to immersion both at rest and during exercise, will aid the physical therapist when designing a rehabilitation or training program for the athlete. Understanding the principles of movement in water will provide a foundation for creative use of water's unique properties.
J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 1998;27(1):32-41.
Key Words: aquatic, training, rehabilitation
View Abstract
View Full Article
Literature Review
Daniel Cipriani, Jeff D. Swartz, Cynthia M. Hodgson
The sport of triathlon is a rapidly growing arena for athletic competition and training. Men and women of various fitness backgrounds have become involved in this sport that involves the disciplines of swimming, cycling, and running. Training for multiple sports has the advantages of providing the athlete with a variety of means of maintaining fitness in the event of an injury. On the other hand, multisport training may also contribute to a special category of injuries, those related to the cumulative effects of cross training. The purpose of this paper is to provide a review of the literature regarding triathlon training and injuries. A survey of a local triathlon club regarding the incidence of injuries is presented, and comparisons are made with previously published surveys. Finally, this paper attempts to outline the training conditions of the triathlete and to provide readers with strategies for injury management.
J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 1998;27(1):42-50.
Key Words: triathlon, epidemiology, training
View Abstract
View Full Article